Climate change shifts organisms in space and time

Duke University Biologist Bill Morris. Credit: Duke University

Duke University Biologist Bill Morris. Credit: Duke University

As our climate changes, we might expect to see some familiar plants and animals in our local environment replaced by new ones. That’s according to Bill Morris from Duke University in Durham, North Carolina, who recently published work studying shifts in where mountain plants live in top science journal Nature. “Species will likely be found in different places than where they are found now, creating new combinations that did not interact in the recent past,” he told Simple Climate. “What the consequences of these new interactions will be are hard to predict, because it is difficult to study interactions that don’t currently exist.”

Together with Daniel Doak at the University of Wyoming, Morris studied two tundra plant species whose habitat extends south from the Arctic. Higher global temperatures are expected to make conditions for the moss campion and alpine bistort better at the northern end of their geographical ranges. By contrast, at the southern end higher temperatures might be expected cause the plants to decline. Consequently their southern range limit should move northwards, but Morris and Doak found that in fact this had not happened – at least not yet.

Morris explained that the question of whether species’ ranges are spreading, or if it’s more common for the range to stay the same size, but move, remains unanswered. “We have much better evidence that species such as butterflies and birds are shifting toward the poles and to higher elevations, because these species are more often noticed by amateur naturalists, and because they likely move faster than do plants,” he said. “But we do know that many plants in Europe, where historical information about plant distributions is better, have moved to higher elevations over the last century.”

Plants as canaries

Climate shapes the growth and survival of plants, including these moss campions along Alaska's Dalton Highway near the Brooks Range. Credit: Daniel Doak

Climate shapes the growth and survival of plants, including these moss campions along Alaska's Dalton Highway near the Brooks Range. Credit: Daniel Doak

This lack of knowledge helped to make Morris’ recent study more important. “Tundra plants such as moss campion and alpine bistort don’t represent a large fraction of the mass of plants on Earth, so they don’t play as much of a role in storing carbon as, for example, trees,” he conceded. “However, because they are suited to living in cold environments, they may serve as useful ‘canaries in the coal mine’, providing early warning of climate change effects before those effects are observed in other, more abundant plants from warmer environments.”

However, the study was designed to provide more than just basic data about where plants had been found, and instead sought to look in depth at how climate change had affected these two quite distinct species. “To address other questions, we had been studying the moss campion in Alaska’s Wrangell mountains for 6 years when we began our study across North America,” Morris explained. “We chose to add alpine bistort because its growth form is different than the moss campion.”

Bill Morris and Alex Rose measure plants in an alpine cirque above Kennecott, Alaska. Credit: Daniel Doak

Bill Morris and Alex Rose measure plants in an alpine cirque above Kennecott, Alaska. Credit: Daniel Doak

Doak and Morris had to painstakingly tag and catalogue the plants themselves as well as the bulblets they drop in reproduction, a job that has enviable aspects – and some distinctly unenviable ones. “Mountain habitats are certainly nice places to work sometimes,” Morris said. “But when it is 33ºF (0.5ºC) and raining or snowing on Alaska’s North Slope counting small seedlings, we might sometimes dream of being on a tropical beach. Also, because these are low plants, counting and measuring them means working on hands and knees for weeks on end. But then again, hiking up the mountains to where these plants live does keep you in good physical shape!”

Tipping point

The researchers’ cataloguing allowed them to assess the “vital rates” of the plants – survival, growth and reproduction – at four different locations. From one perspective perhaps the plants’ extended range stems from their hardiness. “Both have proven to be very long-lived plants,” Morris said. “For example, some moss campion plants can attain an age of over 200 years.” The detailed analysis showed that some vital rates are suffering due to climate change, but others are benefiting, which is why the plants’ geographical ranges are not currently shrinking. Yet ultimately, continued increases in temperature can be expected to adversely impact all vital rates, Morris underlined. “Our study shows that species can show little response to climate change for a long while, and then suddenly shift as a climatic tipping point is surpassed,” he said.

Multi-colored party toothpicks mark individual alpine bistort plants in the Alaskan tundra. Credit: Daniel Doak

Multi-colored party toothpicks mark individual alpine bistort plants in the Alaskan tundra. Credit: Daniel Doak

Morris explained that global warming’s effect on location could have a serious impact on some organisms. “With more greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, we will have a warmer world with altered patterns of precipitation,” he said. “Both of these changes will alter where each species can live.” Morris explains that such altered locations have been seen in the past, and more recently some have already been seen over the last century. Based on the fates recorded for past species some, but not all, will be able to respond to the changes effectively, Morris underlined. “Some species may be able to make the shift to the new locations, or evolve to tolerate new conditions where they are not found, but others may not, and will face extinction in the future climate.”

Although altered locations may be most obvious in some ways, Morris notes that other effects of climate change on plants could be even more important. “Perhaps even more noticeable than shifts in species’ geographical ranges so far is changes in the timing of life events such as plants flowering or birds migrating,” he said. “A big concern is that, if these changes are not synchronous, flowers may be out of sync with their pollinators, birds out of sync with the insects they feed on.”


5 Responses to “Climate change shifts organisms in space and time”

  1. Mark Says:

    Great write-up! The way I see it is that certain lifeforms – particularly the most basic lifeforms such as plants and small creatures – will struggle to adapt to such drastic changes in climate unlike us highly intelligent, resourceful and highly adaptable human beings. when these tipping points are reached, they will have ongoing effects throughout the ecosystem. and who knows to what end.

  2. Climate will thwart some mammals’ quest for new homes « Simple Climate Says:

    […] have already shown that where plants and animals can be found has moved in response to a changing climate. And while many studies have […]

  3. Cause vagueness hinders climate extinction action « Simple Climate Says:

    […] about climate-related extinction in this way. “Instead, papers have focused on documenting shifts in geographic ranges and timing, and in predicting how ranges will shift using modelling approaches,” he said. “These types of […]

  4. Temperature cuts swathe through Australian seaweed « Simple Climate Says:

    […] in the research journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B on Wednesday. Though the ranges many species can be found in have been moving towards cooler places near the poles, Dan says this is among the first evidence for such shifts in ocean ecosystems. “Our study showed […]

  5. Warming makes flowers change dates, or don skates | Simple Climate Says:

    […] change is also driving plants into new homes, mostly towards cooler conditions nearer the poles or uphill. Both timing and growth site changes happen because each species is used to living in niches that […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: